Skip to main content
Advertising

Broaddus: Analyzing QBs With Intriguing Tools, Athleticism

Barkley_042213_650.jpg


IRVING, Texas – This year's draft lacks the same star power at quarterback as last year, but here are a few quarterbacks that could go in the early or middle rounds of this year's draft:

  • *Matt Barkley       USC                    *

Gets his shoulders around when he throws on the boot
accurate on the move
ball out quick on short side screen
can get rid the ball on the HOT
can throw to a spot
was a little careless with the ball against Syracuse and UCLA
tries to slide forward in the pocket when throwing the ball
nice slant for a touchdown when feet were not set
can bring the receiver down the stem
can change his arm angle to make throws
will check the ball down
nice touch to Woods on the "9" along the sideline
threw it right in the window
knows where the blitzer is coming from
doesn't make the WR work for the ball
will set the protection
puts the deep ball in a good spot
makes quick decisions
took big hit in UCLA game which resulted in a fumble
can lead a receiver across the field
gets the ball to the right guy
can float the ball to the flat
always has defenders around him in the pocket
touch to the sideline
gets rid of the ball when not open
made a great read on single high safety for a touchdown against Oregon
keeps his eyes down the field
was hurried in the UCLA game and not as accurate


  • *Geno Smith         West Virginia     *

Operates mainly out of the shot gun
tends to stare at his receiver
will take a hit in the pocket but will deliver the ball
outstanding mobility
bounces on his feet in the pocket
plays on his toes
strong arm
can throw it on the line
can throw in a tight window
tries to fit it in down the field between defenders
will throw the ball away if in trouble
can make throws off balance
had ball knocked out of his hand in the pocket against Texas
needs to be more accurate on the slant
might be making up his mind pre snap of where to throw the ball
showed some touch on the swing against TCU
times where he holds the ball
can buy a second chance with his feet
will get careless with mechanics
.will make some poor choices with the ball throwing down the middle
can hit his man on the move
made some tough throws on 4th down against Texas and TCU
strength to avoid the rush
can make those backside throws
made throw from left hash all the way to the right against Oklahoma
can drive the ball when he has too
led receiver down the sideline against Oklahoma for a touchdown
I believe there a plenty to work with here
.his mobility gives him a chance
smart, hard-working kid that has tools
.

  • *Tyler Wilson        Arkansas            *

Can fit the ball inside
will stand in the pocket to deliver the pass
at times will look at the receiver late, then try and get him the ball
had some bad interceptions
I didn't see much zip on the ball
can throw it on the move going to his left
can put the ball in spots
really has to wind up to get the ball down the field
is not a very mobile quarterback
likes to throw ball underneath but might be because the struggles of the offensive line
made a nice throw on the "4" or the In against South Carolina
was able to hit his man on the move
cannot run away from trouble
made a bad decision on the read option, took a tackle for a loss
throws the ball with a three quarter motion
will hang in the pocket
took a huge hit from Clowney and delivered a touchdown strike
.throws a ton of passes off his back foot
don't blame him for not setting his feet
plays with some awareness in the pocket
.thought he was a much better player as a Junior than Senior but all that he went through most likely had an effect on him
was not impressive in his live work at Senior Bowl
wasn't accurate at all with his passes
.probably a better player overall than the one I am describing but has been a struggle for him
.

  • *Mike Glennon     North Carolina St            *

Smooth throwing motion
can throw the ball on the line
can lead the receiver up the field
nice touch laying the ball to the outside for the receiver to run under
can throw the "9" with touch and accuracy
showed some touch on the swing pass in the flat
had a fumble on a sack in the pocket against Miami
.can fit the ball between defenders
will check down if he doesn't have anything down field
showed the ability to slide in the pocket and avoid but would not call him a threat to run with the ball
keeps his eyes down the field when his receiver broke free
showed the ability to get the ball off
little high versus Florida State on the curl
can high the crossing route
type of quarterback that lets routes develop than makes the throw
found a busted coverage against North Carolina that resulted in a touchdown
will stand very tall in the pocket but not a statue
his best trait in my view is his touch
observed a 55 and 60 yard pass in games I studied
believe the arm can make the necessary throws


  • *EJ Manuel            Florida State      *

Throws like he is pushing the ball
shows some touch on the move but not always accurate
is an athlete with the ball in his hands
moves out of the pocket to make throws
can snap it off quickly
made a nice throw down the middle of the field off the zone read, managed to get it over the top of the linebacker
shows arm strength
made an off balance throw on a "9" for a touchdown
will struggle with accuracy
had man wide open in the corner against Miami but [embedded_ad]

overthrew him
had a fumble in the same game when he was aware in the pocket of the rush
is not consistent with his throwing motion
careless
threw the ball up for grabs in the Florida when he was under pressure
doesn't appear like he reads coverage well
another interception with a crossing route where he didn't see the linebacker
He tends to hold the ball too long in the pocket and seemed rattled by pressure
was much better in the Senior Bowl when it came to throwing the ball after he looked awful during the practices
would not draft him if you just studied the Florida game
might have more athletic ability than Geno Smith in this draft but his throwing motion is going to have to be completely redone
.

This article has been reproduced in a new format and may be missing content or contain faulty links. Please use the Contact Us link in our site footer to report an issue.

Related Content

Advertising